Withdrawal source order with entered tax rates · Calculation guide

Compare two account withdrawal orders for a fixed net income need.

Calculation guide

Use a flat effective tax rate on every gross unit withdrawn from each account. Compare A-first and B-first for one period. Excludes progressive bands, future taxes and mandatory withdrawals.

Gross withdrawal = smaller of available balance and remaining net need ÷ (1 − account tax rate).

Inputs

Net income needed

Example entry 5000 (in the selected currency).

Account A balance

Example entry 5000 (in the selected currency).

Effective tax on A withdrawals

Example entry 20 %. Allowed range 0 to 100.

Account B balance

Example entry 5000 (in the selected currency).

Effective tax on B withdrawals

Example entry 0 %. Allowed range 0 to 100.

Worked example

InputValue
Net income needed5,000
Account A balance5,000
Effective tax on A withdrawals20%
Account B balance5,000
Effective tax on B withdrawals0%
ResultValue
Tax paid with A first1,000
Tax paid with B first0
Unfunded net income0

How each input affects this example

Each row starts from the worked example and changes one input.

InputOriginal inputNew inputAffected resultOriginal resultNew result
Net income needed5,0005,500Tax paid with B first0125
Account A balance5,0005,500Tax paid with A first1,0001,100
Effective tax on A withdrawals20%22%Tax paid with A first1,0001,100
Account B balance5,0004,500Tax paid with B first0125
Effective tax on B withdrawals0%1%Tax paid with A first1,0001,010.10101
Withdrawal source order with entered tax rates →

Sources