Traditional versus Roth after-tax withdrawal · Calculation guide

Compare spendable withdrawals from the same pre-tax earnings budget.

Calculation guide

US workplace 401(k) scenario under 2026 rules. Assume permitted contributions, a fully pre-tax traditional account and a qualified designated Roth distribution after five tax years and age 59½, disability or death. Apply the entered effective tax rates, identical investment growth and no employer match, fees or penalties.

adv = budget*growth*(now-later)/100 · traditional = budget*growth*(1-later/100) · roth = budget*(1-now/100)*growth

Inputs

Pre-tax earnings available

Example entry 10000 USD.

Effective tax on earnings contributed to Roth

Example entry 25 %. Allowed range 0 to 100.

Effective tax on traditional withdrawal

Example entry 20 %. Allowed range 0 to 100.

Investment growth multiplier (2 = doubled)

Example entry 2.

Worked example

InputValue
Pre-tax earnings available10,000 USD
Effective tax on earnings contributed to Roth25%
Effective tax on traditional withdrawal20%
Investment growth multiplier (2 = doubled)2
ResultValue
Traditional after-tax advantage1,000 USD
Spendable traditional distribution16,000 USD
Qualified Roth distribution15,000 USD

Calculation steps

Traditional after-tax advantage = (((Pre-tax earnings available × Investment growth multiplier (2 = doubled)) × (Effective tax on earnings contributed to Roth − Effective tax on traditional withdrawal)) ÷ 100)

(((10,000 × 2) × (25 − 20)) ÷ 100) = 1,000 USD

Spendable traditional distribution = ((Pre-tax earnings available × Investment growth multiplier (2 = doubled)) × (1 − (Effective tax on traditional withdrawal ÷ 100)))

((10,000 × 2) × (1 − (20 ÷ 100))) = 16,000 USD

Qualified Roth distribution = ((Pre-tax earnings available × (1 − (Effective tax on earnings contributed to Roth ÷ 100))) × Investment growth multiplier (2 = doubled))

((10,000 × (1 − (25 ÷ 100))) × 2) = 15,000 USD

How each input affects this example

Each row starts from the worked example and changes one input.

InputOriginal inputNew inputAffected resultOriginal resultNew result
Pre-tax earnings available10,000 USD11,000 USDTraditional after-tax advantage1,000 USD1,100 USD
Effective tax on earnings contributed to Roth25%28%Traditional after-tax advantage1,000 USD1,600 USD
Effective tax on traditional withdrawal20%22%Traditional after-tax advantage1,000 USD600 USD
Investment growth multiplier (2 = doubled)23Traditional after-tax advantage1,000 USD1,500 USD
Traditional versus Roth after-tax withdrawal →

Sources