Shutdown versus continue cash loss · Calculation guide

Compare both alternatives for the same period.

Calculation guide

Unavoidable fixed cash costs continue either way. Include one-off shutdown and restart cash costs; exclude depreciation.

Net cash from continuing = Operating cash receipts if open − Variable cash costs if open − Avoidable fixed cash cost − Unavoidable fixed cash cost. Net cash from shutdown = 0 − Unavoidable fixed cash cost − Shutdown and restart cash cost. Cash advantage of shutdown = Net cash from shutdown − Net cash from continuing

Inputs

Operating cash receipts if open

Example entry 6000 (in the selected currency).

Variable cash costs if open

Example entry 4500 (in the selected currency).

Avoidable fixed cash cost

Example entry 1800 (in the selected currency).

Unavoidable fixed cash cost

Example entry 700 (in the selected currency).

Shutdown and restart cash cost

Example entry 200 (in the selected currency).

Worked example

InputValue
Operating cash receipts if open6,000
Variable cash costs if open4,500
Avoidable fixed cash cost1,800
Unavoidable fixed cash cost700
Shutdown and restart cash cost200
ResultValue
Net cash from continuing-1,000
Net cash from shutdown-900
Cash advantage of shutdown100

Calculation steps

Net cash from continuing = (((Operating cash receipts if open − Variable cash costs if open) − Avoidable fixed cash cost) − Unavoidable fixed cash cost)

(((6,000 − 4,500) − 1,800) − 700) = -1,000

Net cash from shutdown = ((0 − Unavoidable fixed cash cost) − Shutdown and restart cash cost)

((0 − 700) − 200) = -900

Cash advantage of shutdown = (Net cash from shutdown − Net cash from continuing)

(-900 − -1,000) = 100

How each input affects this example

Each row starts from the worked example and changes one input.

InputOriginal inputNew inputAffected resultOriginal resultNew result
Operating cash receipts if open6,0006,600Net cash from continuing-1,000-400
Variable cash costs if open4,5004,950Net cash from continuing-1,000-1,450
Avoidable fixed cash cost1,8001,980Net cash from continuing-1,000-1,180
Unavoidable fixed cash cost700770Net cash from continuing-1,000-1,070
Shutdown and restart cash cost200220Net cash from shutdown-900-920
Shutdown versus continue cash loss →

Sources