Insurance deductible break-even · Calculation guide

How often would a claim erase the premium saving from a higher deductible?

Calculation guide

Both policies cover the same losses. Each modeled claim reaches both deductibles and triggers a separate deductible. The threshold is an annual claim frequency, which may exceed one claim per year.

claims = (premium_low-premium_high)/(high-low); saving = premium_low-premium_high; extra = high-low

Inputs

Lower deductible

Example entry 250 (in the selected currency).

Higher deductible

Example entry 750 (in the selected currency).

Annual premium with lower deductible

Example entry 1300 (in the selected currency).

Annual premium with higher deductible

Example entry 1050 (in the selected currency).

Worked example

InputValue
Lower deductible250
Higher deductible750
Annual premium with lower deductible1,300
Annual premium with higher deductible1,050
ResultValue
Break-even claims per year0.5
Annual premium saving250
Extra cost per modeled claim500

Calculation steps

Break-even claims per year = ((Annual premium with lower deductible − Annual premium with higher deductible) ÷ (Higher deductible − Lower deductible))

((1,300 − 1,050) ÷ (750 − 250)) = 0.5

Annual premium saving = (Annual premium with lower deductible − Annual premium with higher deductible)

(1,300 − 1,050) = 250

Extra cost per modeled claim = (Higher deductible − Lower deductible)

(750 − 250) = 500

How each input affects this example

Each row starts from the worked example and changes one input.

InputOriginal inputNew inputAffected resultOriginal resultNew result
Lower deductible250275Break-even claims per year0.50.526316
Higher deductible750825Break-even claims per year0.50.434783
Annual premium with lower deductible1,3001,430Break-even claims per year0.50.76
Annual premium with higher deductible1,0501,155Break-even claims per year0.50.29
Insurance deductible break-even →