Implementation shortfall versus arrival price · Calculation guide

Measure execution cost and missed-trade opportunity against the arrival benchmark.

Calculation guide

Mark unfilled units at the final observed price. A positive shortfall is an adverse outcome for either side.

Cost = side × [Σ(fill − arrival) × units + (end − arrival) × missed units] + fees.

Inputs

Order quantity

Example entry 100.

Arrival benchmark

Example entry 100 (in the selected currency).

Final mark

Example entry 105 (in the selected currency).

Total commissions and fees

Example entry 4 (in the selected currency).

Order side

Select one of the listed cases (Buy / Sell).

Price per unit

Example entry 100 (in the selected currency). Minimum 1e-08.

Units

Example entry 30. Minimum 1e-08.

Worked example

InputValue
Order quantity100
Arrival benchmark100
Final mark105
Total commissions and fees4
Order sideBuy

Executed fills

Price per unitUnits
10030
10250
ResultValue
Total implementation shortfall204
Executed price cost100
Opportunity cost on unfilled units100

How each input affects this example

Each row starts from the worked example and changes one input.

InputOriginal inputNew inputAffected resultOriginal resultNew result
Order quantity100110Total implementation shortfall204254
Arrival benchmark100110Total implementation shortfall204-796
Final mark105116Total implementation shortfall204424
Total commissions and fees45Total implementation shortfall204205
Order sideBuySellTotal implementation shortfall204-196
Price per unit (row 1)100110Total implementation shortfall204504
Units (row 1)3033Total implementation shortfall204189
Implementation shortfall versus arrival price →