Deferred annuity surrender versus continuation · Calculation guide

Compare the assumed future value of surrender proceeds with continuation of the contract.

Calculation guide

Apply the quoted surrender charge now. Annual rates are effective after ongoing fees, before personal tax. Use a horizon with no remaining surrender charge on the continued contract. Exclude insurance riders and guarantees.

continued = value*(1+keep/100)^years · reinvested = (value-charge)*(1+alt/100)^years · diff = continued-reinvested

Inputs

Current contract value

Example entry 10000 (in the selected currency).

Current surrender charge

Example entry 500 (in the selected currency).

Contract annual net growth

Example entry 2 %. Allowed range -50.0 to 50.0.

Alternative annual net growth

Example entry 4 %. Allowed range -50.0 to 50.0.

Comparison years

Example entry 2. Allowed range 1.0 to 100.0. Use whole numbers.

Worked example

InputValue
Current contract value10,000
Current surrender charge500
Contract annual net growth2%
Alternative annual net growth4%
Comparison years2
ResultValue
Future value if continued10,404
Future value if surrendered and reinvested10,275.2
Continuation advantage128.8

Calculation steps

Future value if continued = (Current contract value × ((1 + (Contract annual net growth ÷ 100)) ^ Comparison years))

(10,000 × ((1 + (2 ÷ 100)) ^ 2)) = 10,404

Future value if surrendered and reinvested = ((Current contract value − Current surrender charge) × ((1 + (Alternative annual net growth ÷ 100)) ^ Comparison years))

((10,000 − 500) × ((1 + (4 ÷ 100)) ^ 2)) = 10,275.2

Continuation advantage = (Future value if continued − Future value if surrendered and reinvested)

(10,404 − 10,275.2) = 128.8

How each input affects this example

Each row starts from the worked example and changes one input.

InputOriginal inputNew inputAffected resultOriginal resultNew result
Current contract value10,00011,000Future value if continued10,40411,444.4
Current surrender charge500550Future value if surrendered and reinvested10,275.210,221.12
Contract annual net growth2%3%Future value if continued10,40410,609
Alternative annual net growth4%5%Future value if surrendered and reinvested10,275.210,473.75
Comparison years23Future value if continued10,40410,612.08
Deferred annuity surrender versus continuation →

Sources